Effects of focus and definiteness on children's word order: evidence from German five-year-olds' reproductions of double object constructions*
نویسندگان
چکیده
Two experiments tested how faithfully German children aged 4 ;5 to 5 ;6 reproduce ditransitive sentences that are unmarked or marked with respect to word order and focus (Exp1) or definiteness (Exp2). Adopting an optimality theory (OT) approach, it is assumed that in the German adult grammar word order is ranked lower than focus and definiteness. Faithfulness of children's reproductions decreased as markedness of inputs increased; unmarked structures were reproduced most faithfully and unfaithful outputs had most often an unmarked form. Consistent with the OT proposal, children were more tolerant against inputs marked for word order than for focus; in conflict with the proposal, children were less tolerant against inputs marked for word order than for definiteness. Our results suggest that the linearization of objects in German double object constructions is affected by focus and definiteness, but that prosodic principles may have an impact on the position of a focused constituent.
منابع مشابه
Rules and construction effects in learning the argument structure of verbs.
Theorists of language acquisition have long debated the means by which children learn the argument structure of verbs (e.g. Bowerman, 1974, 1990; Pinker, 1984, 1989; Tomasello, 1992). Central to this controversy has been the possible role of verb semantics, especially in learning which verbs undergo dative-shift alternation in languages like English. The learning problem is somewhat simplified ...
متن کاملGerman children's comprehension of word order and case marking in causative sentences.
Two comprehension experiments were conducted to investigate whether German children are able to use the grammatical cues of word order and word endings (case markers) to identify agents and patients in a causative sentence and whether they weigh these two cues differently across development. Two-year-olds correctly understood only sentences with both cues supporting each other--the prototypical...
متن کاملCorpus-and Psycholinguistic Investigations of Linguistic Constraints on German Object Order
The aim of this paper is to evaluate several linguistic constraints as predictors of the frequency with which word order variants of double object sentences occur, as well as of the processing ease associated with these structures. We will provide corpus data and behavioural data from completion questionnaires and self-paced reading experiments that address the validity of the Dative constraint...
متن کاملSyntax and Discourse Factors in Early New High German: Evidence for Verb-Final Word Order
Several recent studies have taken the approach that the word order variation in Early New High German (1300-1600) is indicative of a change in the underlying syntax. In this thesis, I argue that Early New High German (ENHG) was solidly verb-final in structure throughout its history and that the evidence for the existence of structurally INFL-medial sentences in ENHG is not convincing. I find no...
متن کاملGerman children's comprehension of word order and case marking
In this paper we explored factors that affect how children learning German understand which participant is the agent and which the patient in simple causative sentences (i.e. who does what to whom). Most languages, including German, have multiple cues to mark these roles. In two comprehension experiments we examined whether German children are able to use the grammatical cues of word order and ...
متن کامل